Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme
Browse By

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

This page groups beliefs by their standing within a body of teaching. Wikipedia notes that "beliefs are the subject of various important philosophical debates," including how "fine-grained or coarse-grained" a given belief actually is. Browsing by status-within-the-tradition lets a visitor tell a settled belief from a contested one.

Facts
Overview
What Defines This Grouping
Single tenets, rules and prohibitions isolated from the traditions that hold them and stated in that tradition's own terms with the reason it offers. Organising religion around propositional belief is itself a Western and largely post-Reformation habit: several traditions treat practice, lineage or law as primary and have no close equivalent of the noun. 1
Status
Standing as a Comparative Category
Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputed 1
Learn More
What a Tradition Holds and Requires

This category holds the specific things traditions believe and require: articles of faith, dietary rules, prohibitions, obligations and taboos. Where a religion entry describes a whole tradition, a belief entry isolates a single tenet or rule (the oneness of God, the prohibition of certain foods, an obligation of charity, a taboo on certain acts), and states it plainly.

Each entry names the tradition that holds the belief, states it in that tradition's own terms, and gives the reason the tradition itself offers, so that comparable beliefs across traditions can be set side by side.

Belief and boundary

Beliefs and the rules that follow from them often mark the boundary of a community, what its members affirm and how they must live, and small differences in them can distinguish one tradition or denomination from another. The atlas treats each as the tradition presents it, without ranking or refuting.

The beliefs group by kind (core tenets, cosmological beliefs, moral precepts, dietary restrictions, prohibitions and taboos), so a browser can compare, for instance, the dietary rules of several traditions together. The enacted side of religious life, rites, practices and festivals, is treated under its own categories.

Genuinely disputed within the tradition
Filter Results22 entries

A closed community forbidding conversion and intermarriage

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Ahura Mazda as the one supreme creator

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Al-Masalih al-Mursala: Unstated Public Benefit Is a Ground for Ruling

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Buddha-nature in all beings

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Cessation of the miraculous spiritual gifts

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Do Ut Des: I Give So That You May Give

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Esoteric interpretation of scripture (batin)

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Istihsan: A Jurist May Set Aside a Strict Analogy for a Better Ruling

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Juristic Preference Is Not a Valid Source of Law

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Music and Dance Have No Place on the Path

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Mystical union with God (fana)

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Sama: Music and Listening Carry the Seeker Toward God

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Surrender Is a Sufficient Means of Liberation

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

The covenant between God and Israel

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

The full inclusion of LGBTQ people in ordination and marriage

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

The Gohonzon as the object of devotion

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

The ordination of women

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

The Threefold Law

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

The Torah is divinely revealed and binding

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Veneration of Ali as a divine manifestation

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Wahdat al-Wujud: All That Exists Is One Reality

Genuinely disputed within the tradition

Withstanding Fire and Blades Testifies to the Saint's State

Genuinely disputed within the tradition
Sources
1. Belief, Language, and Experience
Rodney Needham, Basil Blackwell, 1972
Divinity Atlas Directory Prose, First Edition Category Descriptions
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.