The prologue, deliberately echoing Genesis 1:1. 'Word' renders logos, which in Greek philosophy meant reason or ordering principle as much as speech; the choice to translate it as Word rather than leave it as Logos is itself a decision. The last clause of verse 1 lacks the article in Greek, which some read as 'the Word was divine' rather than 'was God', the reading Jehovah's Witnesses build on, and the one most Greek grammarians reject.
Facts
Passage
TextIn the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. The same was in the beginning with God. All things were made through him; and without him was not anything made that hath been made. 1 Reference Scheme Translation
TranslationThe Holy Bible, American Standard Version 1 TranslatorAmerican Revision Committee 1 Learn More
Why Logos Could Not Simply Stay Untranslated
Raymond Brown's commentary on John places the Prologue's opening at the meeting point of two traditions the Gospel never separates cleanly. Jewish wisdom literature already speaks of Wisdom present with God before creation and active in making the world, the same figure the midrash on Genesis reads into Bereshit; the Stoic and Middle Platonist philosophical tradition already used logos for the rational principle that orders the universe. Brown argues the Gospel's first audience could hear both registers in the same word, which is exactly what makes translating it into a single English word difficult. Word carries the sense of speech and command; it loses the sense of ordering reason that logos held for a reader trained in Greek philosophy, and no English word does both at once.
The grammatical wrinkle already noted on this passage, that the final clause lacks the definite article, is not a translator's oversight but a genuine ambiguity in the Greek that later doctrinal disputes turned into a battleground. Brown reads the anarthrous construction as qualitative, describing what the Word is rather than counting a second god beside the first, the reading that became orthodox, against readings that took the missing article as license to make the Word a lesser, created being.
Connections
Associated With
This source names Jehovah's Witnesses directly: "rather than 'was God', the reading Jehovah's Witnesses build on, and the one most Greek grammarians reject."
Source The Holy Bible, American Standard Version (1901), verse-per-line textAmerican Revision Committee
Concerns
Hermeticism, Religions Logos as ordering principle is shared ground with Hermetic and Stoic thought.
The verse nontrinitarian readings turn on.
The principal New Testament ground for the doctrine of the Trinity.
Passage Of
Source The Holy Bible, American Standard Version (1901), verse-per-line textAmerican Revision Committee
Sources
1. The Holy Bible, American Standard Version (1901), verse-per-line text
American Revision Committee, eBible.org (digital edition), 1901John 1:1-3View the Source Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.