Home›Rituals›Scholarly Standing›Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedBrowse ByUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedThis page groups rituals by how settled or contested their scholarly description is. Wikipedia notes plainly that "the field of ritual studies has seen a number of conflicting definitions of the term." Browsing this way lets a visitor see which rituals scholars broadly agree on and which remain genuinely disputed.FactsLearn MoreUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedSourcesComments (0)Reader Challenges (0)FactsOriginsWhose Classification This IsWell-attestedThe modern comparative category was assembled in the nineteenth century out of Protestant polemic against ceremony and evolutionist anthropology's myth-and-rite debate. Its present shape owes most to van Gennep's rites of passage (1909), Turner's liminality (1969) and Bell's six genres of ritual action (1997). These are scholars' frames, not the traditions' own. 1OverviewWhat Defines This GroupingWell-attestedFormal, patterned rites performed on set occasions - sacraments, initiations, rites of passage, calendrical observances - as distinct from the disciplines sustained over time, which the atlas treats as practices. Ritual is the most heavily theorised category in the study of religion, and the line it draws is analytic: no tradition sorts its own acts into these classes. 1StatusStanding as a Comparative CategoryWell-attestedA standard analytic category in the study of religion 1Learn MoreThe Formal Rites A ritual is a formal, patterned rite performed on an occasion: a sacrament, an initiation, a calendrical observance, a rite of passage, a consecration. This category gathers the set rites of religious and esoteric practice, recording for each what the rite consists of, the tradition that performs it, and what it is held to accomplish. Rites tend to be prescribed and repeatable, done in a set way, at set times or on set occasions, and much of a tradition's life is carried in them: birth, initiation, marriage and death are marked by rite in nearly every tradition, as are the turning-points of the year.What Rites Do Traditions understand their rites in different ways, as effecting a real change (a sacrament that conveys grace, an initiation that alters status), as commemorating an event, as maintaining a cosmic or social order, or as a means of purification or protection, and the entries record the tradition's own understanding. The rituals group by function (initiatory, calendrical, funerary, purification, sacrificial, devotional and the rest), so a reader can compare how different traditions mark the same passage. The ongoing disciplines of religious life, as opposed to set rites, are treated as practices.Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedFilter Results13 entriesAddressed ToAllAmma (1)Origin Period Start YearAll-2600 (2)-1650 (1)-957 (1)600 (1)1970 (1)Attested InAllBook of the Dead (1)Mishnah (2)Popol Vuh (1)FrequencyAllAs the occasion requires (8)Multi-Year Cycle (1)Once, or at a turning point in a life (3)Several times a day (1)Life Stage MarkedAllDeath and the disposal of the body (1)Dying and the deathbed (1)Entry into the community or the order (1)ObligationAllObligatory (1)Recommended and meritorious, not required (1)Social FormAllPerformed by a gathered group (2)Performed by an officiant for a recipient (1)Practice StatusAllEnded (2)Living tradition, practised today (3)PractitionerAllAll adherents of the tradition (3)Clergy or ordained officiants (6)Householders, those living in the world (1)The candidate undergoing the rite (1)Trained or authorised specialists (2)Native To RegionAllAncient Israel (3)Arabia (1)Egypt (2)Greece (1)Japan (1)Mesoamerica (1)TraditionAllBreslov Hasidism (1)Chabad-Lubavitch (1)Conservative Judaism (1)Eastern Orthodoxy (1)Haredi Judaism (1)Hasidic Judaism (1)Modern Orthodox Judaism (1)Orthodox Judaism (1)Reform Judaism (1)Originated InAllAncient Israel (2)Arabia (1)Egypt (2)Greece (1)Japan (1)Mesoamerica (1)The Levant (2)Originates In LanguageAllAncient Egyptian Language (1)Classical Arabic (1)Hebrew (1)Kind of ritualAllAncient Egyptian Mortuary Rites (1)Buddhist Funerary Tradition (1)Classical, Norse and Mesopotamian Funerary Rites (1)Indigenous Sacrificial Ceremonies and Sacred Games (1)Jewish and Islamic Coming-of-Age and Conversion Rites (1)Show ResultsBrowseCompareSelect all 13Asham (The Reparation Offering)Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedByzantine Imperial CoronationUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedGiyurUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedKorban (The Israelite Offering)Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedMesoamerican BallgameUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedMizuko KuyoUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedNorse Ship BurialUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedOpening of the MouthUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedSenetUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedTalqinUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedTamid (The Daily Offering)Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedThe Dogon Sigui CeremonyUsed, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedThysia (Greek Animal Sacrifice)Used, but its validity as a comparative category is disputedSources1. Ritual: Perspectives and Dimensionstier 1Catherine Bell, Oxford University Press, 1997View the SourceDivinity Atlas Directory Prose, First Edition Category Descriptionstier 1Comments (0)No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.Sign in to join the discussion.Reader Challenges (0)No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.