Independent investigation of the Kirlian effect, carried out by researchers outside the original Soviet program from the 1970s onward, found that the coronal discharge captured on film could be reliably reproduced and altered by manipulating entirely ordinary physical variables, moisture content, pressure applied to the electrode, electrical grounding, and the voltage and frequency of the field itself, without any need to posit a life-specific bioplasmic energy to account for the images, a conclusion summarized in skeptical reference works such as Robert Todd Carroll's The Skeptic's Dictionary. Because these physical variables alone could account for the corona's appearance and its variation between living and even non-living or freshly cut biological samples, mainstream biophysics did not adopt bioplasma as a genuine fifth state of matter, and the theory has not been supported by controlled research conducted since the 1970s and 1980s reassessment of Kirlian photography.
Bioplasma's imagery and vocabulary nonetheless persisted well beyond the scientific reassessment, feeding into later Western popular writing on the human aura and energy healing in ways that echo, and were sometimes directly cited alongside, the older Theosophical etheric and astral concepts and Reichenbach's nineteenth century od, part of a recurring pattern in which a scientifically framed claim about a life-specific energy field, once its physical explanation is established, continues to circulate in popular and alternative-healing culture regardless. Bioplasma is presented here as a documented Soviet-era research program and the specific test result that followed it, not as an open scientific question.