The Smith family settled near Palmyra around 1816 and began working the farm two years later, only to lose it to debt in 1825, after which it passed through a succession of other owners for more than eighty years. The church did not acquire the property until 1907, during a period when it was actively purchasing and marking its historic sites across the eastern states, and it has held the farm continuously since.
The exact spot within the woodland where the vision is said to have occurred was never recorded, and the church has never claimed to identify one particular tree or clearing, which is the reason no marker stands anywhere inside the grove itself. Joseph Smith gave several accounts of the vision between 1832 and 1842, and the differences among them, in what is described and what is emphasized from one telling to the next, are a genuine subject of scholarly discussion that the church itself has addressed directly in a published essay rather than leaving to outside critics alone.
The log home and frame home associated with the Smith family have since been reconstructed or restored on the property and are shown to visitors alongside the woodland itself. The grove has been managed as working forest since the 1907 purchase, with some replanting over the decades, so the trees standing today are not, in every case, the same ones that stood above a fourteen year old boy in 1820.