An Historical and Critical Account of the So-Called Prophecy of St. Malachy Regarding the Succession of Popes, by M. J. O'Brien, published by M. H. Gill and Son in 1880, is a Catholic priest's own scholarly investigation into the popular prophecy attributing to the twelfth century Irish saint a list of cryptic mottoes predicting every pope down to the end of the Church. Its strength is source criticism of real rigor, O'Brien traced the mottoes' actual origin to a sixteenth century papal history by Panvinio and showed the supposed prophecy's wording depends on and mirrors that later text's own errors, concluding the list was fabricated around 1590 by Fr. Wion rather than composed by Malachy in the twelfth century. Its limit is its age and its clear apologetic purpose, defending the Church against a popular prophecy some readers took as embarrassingly credulous, but the textual argument itself has held up and remains the standard scholarly explanation cited by later historians of the prophecy.
Facts
Assessment
Reliability Tier1
Published by M. H. Gill and Son as M. J. O'Brien's rigorous source-critical scholarly investigation, whose textual argument tracing the prophecy to a sixteenth century fabrication has held up and remains the standard scholarly explanation, treated at the top tier. NotesRestates and extends Menestrier's seventeenth century case against authenticity, with a pope-by-pope commentary on the mottoes.
Citation
AuthorM. J. O'Brien
PublisherM.H. Gill & Son
Publication Year1880
Source Typeacademic monograph
Claims Backed By This Source (40 claims)
This source backs 40 claims across the atlas. As facts: 26 well-attested, 1 partially Attested, 1 scholarly debate, 1 popular myth - corrected. As cited relationships: 4 holds, 3 connected. Plus 4 entities citing it as a general reference with no single fact or relationship attached.
Disposition By Topic
- Articles, 16 claims: 11 well-attested, 1 partially Attested, 2 connected, 2 general references.
- Prophecies, 9 claims: 4 well-attested, 1 scholarly debate, 1 popular myth - corrected, 1 holds, 1 connected, 1 general references.
- Historical Figures, 8 claims: 4 well-attested, 3 holds, 1 general references.
- Sources, 7 claims: 7 well-attested.
Popular myth - corrected
1Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.