Back to Interesting Facts

Coming-of-Age Rites is formally linked to four religions in this atlas: Buddhism, Hinduism, Judaism and Sikhism. All four links are bare, holds with no note attached, so this essay reads its own description, which states its organising question directly: "The question a coming-of-age rite answers is what the community is now entitled to expect."

Four Traditions, Four Different Answers

Judaism's answer is that "the obligation simply arrives with the birthday and the ceremony marks it," an entitlement already in force before any rite is performed. Hinduism's answer is Upanayana, which "invests a boy with the sacred thread and the right to study the Veda," a rite that grants a standing the birthday alone does not. Sikhism's answer is Amrit Sanchar, which "admits a Sikh to the Khalsa and to its discipline, and is undertaken by adults as often as by adolescents," a rite of formal admission rather than one tied to a fixed age at all. Buddhism's answer, in Burma and Thailand, is a boy's temporary ordination as a novice for a period that may be as short as a week, where "the merit accrues to his mother," a rite that confers standing on someone other than the one performing it. The atlas's own summary names what almost none of the four share: "What almost none of these involve is a test; the near-universal shape is instruction, then a public assumption of duty."

A Fifth Answer the Links Do Not Count

Its own description also names Catholic and Anglican confirmation, which "asks the candidate to say for themselves what godparents once said for them," and the Latin American quinceanera, named plainly as "folk practice with a Mass attached rather than a rite of the church." Neither Christianity nor any Catholic or Anglican denomination is formally linked to Coming-of-Age Rites in this atlas; the comparison is its own, offered as context, and this essay reports the four religions the data actually connects rather than the fifth tradition its own prose happens to mention.

One Formula, Held by Six Jewish Bodies, and a Seventh That Adds to It

Beneath Judaism's single religion-level link, seven Jewish denominations carry their own link to Coming-of-Age Rites, and six of them state the identical formula in nearly the same words: Breslov Hasidism, Chabad-Lubavitch, Hasidic Judaism, Modern Orthodox Judaism and Orthodox Judaism each hold that "coming of age is a matter of obligation taking effect at a fixed age rather than of a ceremony conferring it," and Haredi Judaism holds the same position with the added note that its own "halakhic standard is the strictest and the most stringent opinion is ordinarily followed." Reform Judaism is the seventh, and it does not restate the formula; its own account is that coming of age "is marked by Bar and Bat Mitzvah and then by Confirmation," a rite added on top of the obligation rather than a denial that the obligation exists. Six bodies affirm the same position for the same reason; the seventh keeps the position and adds a ceremony the other six treat as unnecessary.

Where To Read More

• Coming-of-Age RitesLifecycle RitualsThe rite itself; four religions counted, each answering a different question by its own account
• BuddhismDharmic (Nontheistic)The Burmese and Thai temporary novitiate; merit accrues to the mother rather than the novice
• HinduismDharmic (Polytheistic)Upanayana, the sacred thread and the right to study the Veda
• JudaismAbrahamic (Monotheistic)The obligation arrives with the birthday; seven denominations carry their own edge beneath this one
• SikhismDharmic (Monotheistic)Amrit Sanchar, admission to the Khalsa undertaken by adults as often as adolescents
• Breslov HasidismJudaismBreslov Hasidism: obligation at a fixed age, not a ceremony conferring it
• Chabad-LubavitchJudaismChabad-Lubavitch: obligation at a fixed age, not a ceremony conferring it
• Haredi JudaismJudaismHaredi Judaism: the same formula, with the strictest halakhic standard ordinarily followed
• Hasidic JudaismJudaismHasidic Judaism: obligation at a fixed age, not a ceremony conferring it
• Modern Orthodox JudaismJudaismModern Orthodox Judaism: the same formula, alongside full engagement with secular study and the state
• Orthodox JudaismJudaismOrthodox Judaism: obligation at a fixed age, not a ceremony conferring it
• Reform JudaismJudaismReform Judaism, the seventh denomination: adds Confirmation after Bar and Bat Mitzvah rather than restating the formula