Miracles
The Hanukkah Oil
Citation Formats
General Reference
APA Style
BibTeX
The story, told in the Babylonian Talmud, that a single flask of ritually pure oil found when the Maccabees rededicated the Jerusalem Temple, enough for one day, burned for eight, which the Talmud gives as the reason for the eight nights of Hanukkah lights. The oldest surviving accounts of the rededication, First and Second Maccabees, describe the eight day festival without mentioning any oil miracle at all, a gap this entry treats as the central fact to be explained rather than an embarrassment to be skipped.
Facts
Disputed
Skeptical ExplanationScholars including Shaye Cohen read the silence of Maccabees and Josephus as evidence the oil story is a later rabbinic elaboration, not part of the earliest layer of Hanukkah tradition. 3 The story that a single day's supply of ritually pure oil burned for eight days when the Second Temple's menorah was rededicated appears in the Talmud, compiled centuries after the Maccabean revolt it describes, and is absent from the earlier Books of Maccabees that otherwise record the rededication itself. Shaye J. D. Cohen's From the Maccabees to the Mishnah (Westminster John Knox Press, 2006), a scholarly account of the rabbinic movement's emergence after 70 CE as a reconstruction of religious authority rather than a continuation of the priesthood, frames how to read later rabbinic material about the Temple period critically. The method is source-critical, checking the earlier Books of Maccabees against the later Talmudic account for what each does and does not report. Because the evidence cannot distinguish a rabbinic composition serving a later liturgical need from a genuinely older oral tradition never written down earlier, the story's origin remains open rather than resolved by either source alone. The Claim
The ClaimThe Babylonian Talmud relates that when the Maccabees rededicated the Temple, they found only one flask of ritually pure oil, enough for one day, and it burned for eight, the Talmud's stated reason for the eight nights of Hanukkah lights. 1Tradition: Rabbinic Judaism Investigation
Investigation VerdictFirst and Second Maccabees, the earliest surviving sources for the 164 BCE rededication, describe the eight day festival but do not mention an oil miracle; Josephus likewise omits it in the first century CE. 2 Learn More
The Story in the Talmud
The Babylonian Talmud, tractate Shabbat, folio 21b, asks directly, "What is Hanukkah?" and answers with a story: when the Hasmoneans (the Maccabees) overcame the occupying forces and entered the Temple to rededicate it, they searched and found only a single flask of oil still bearing the seal of the High Priest, certifying it ritually pure, and it held enough to keep the Temple's lamp burning for a single day. They lit it anyway, and it lasted eight days, the time needed to press and prepare new pure oil. The rabbis, the passage says, established those eight days as a festival of praise and thanksgiving the following year.
This is the account behind the central home ritual of Hanukkah, the lighting of an additional candle on a menorah, or hanukkiah, on each of the festival's eight nights. It is also, notably, not the story told in the earliest surviving sources for the same events. The Talmudic passage itself is brief, only a few lines, compared to the extended halakhic discussion of candle-lighting that surrounds it in the same tractate, which some scholars read as a sign the story was included chiefly to justify a ritual practice already in place rather than as inherited historical memory. Whatever its origin, the story has shaped Hanukkah's central home ritual for over a thousand years and is the version most widely known today.
A Miracle Absent From the Earliest Sources
First and Second Maccabees, written within a generation or two of the events of 164 BCE and the closest surviving sources to them, describe the rededication of the Temple and the establishment of an eight day festival in detail, but neither mentions any oil lasting beyond its measure. Second Maccabees instead explains the eight days as a delayed celebration of Sukkot, the harvest festival the fighters had been unable to observe properly while occupying the Temple. The historian Josephus, writing in the first century CE and closer in time to the Talmud's editors than to the Maccabees, also describes the festival, which he calls the Festival of Lights, without telling the oil story either.
Scholars of Second Temple and rabbinic Judaism, including Shaye Cohen, read this silence as evidence that the oil story is a later rabbinic elaboration rather than part of the earliest layer of Hanukkah tradition, composed or preserved by the rabbis of the Talmudic period for their own reasons, centuries after the fact. Whether the rabbis invented the story outright or drew on an oral tradition that had simply gone unrecorded in the earlier written sources is not something the surviving evidence can settle either way.
Sources First and Second MaccabeesAnonymous with From the Maccabees to the MishnahShaye J. D. Cohen
Cross-Tradition Connections
Associated With
The Talmud's stated reason for the festival's eight nights of lights.
Related To
The doctrine is the general treatment of miracle claims across traditions; what is described here is one specific claim.
Sources
Essays About This Entity (1 essay)
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.
Sign in to dispute this or suggest a correction.
View At A Past Year
The atlas records no dated fact of its own for this entry, so there is no other year to choose.