When Zarathustra lived is one of the most persistently disputed questions in the study of ancient Iranian religion. A traditional chronology, recorded in later Zoroastrian sources, places him two hundred and fifty eight years before Alexander's conquest of Persia, which would put his life in the sixth century BCE, contemporary with the early Achaemenid Persian empire. Linguistic analysis of the Gathas, however, points to a considerably earlier date: the archaic form of Avestan in which they are composed, and the pastoral, tribal society the hymns describe, resemble the world of the Rigveda far more than they resemble the urbanized, imperial Iran of the sixth century BCE, leading many specialists to favor a date somewhere between about 1500 and 1000 BCE instead.
Neither dating rests on independent, externally verifiable evidence in the way that later, better documented periods of Iranian history do, and the disagreement is not simply a matter of preferring one ancient source over another, since the traditional date and the linguistic evidence point in genuinely different directions rather than toward a single reconcilable range. Some scholars have proposed that the later traditional date reflects a real historical figure, perhaps a reformer or systematizer working within an older Zoroastrian tradition, being retrospectively identified with the original prophet, though this remains one hypothesis among several rather than a settled resolution.
The uncertainty over Zarathustra's date is compounded by the near total absence of independent, non-Zoroastrian evidence for his life, leaving the Gathas themselves, read primarily as religious and linguistic evidence rather than as biography, as the main basis scholars have for locating him in time at all.