Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Denominations

Kashmir Shaivism

Also Known As Trika (Sanskrit) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to. · Trika Shaivism (English) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to. · Pratyabhijna (Sanskrit) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to. · Kashmiri Shaivism (English) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to. · Kashmir Saivism (English) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to. · Trika Shastra (Sanskrit) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to. · Spanda (Sanskrit) The form the corpus and the scholarship use, which the display name did not answer to.
Hinduism

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Origin from 800

Kashmir Shaivism is the name given to the nondual Shaiva traditions that flourished in the Kashmir valley between roughly the ninth and the twelfth centuries. Its central claim separates it sharply from the Vedanta most readers meet first: the world is not an illusion to be seen through but the free and deliberate self expression of a single consciousness, which the tradition calls Shiva, and which contracts itself into the appearance of limited selves for the pleasure of doing so. Liberation is therefore not escape but recognition, pratyabhijna, the moment a limited self sees that it was never anything other than the whole. It is also not a single school. Trika, named for the triad it works with, is the framework Abhinavagupta gave the whole; Spanda takes the vibration or pulse of consciousness as its way in; Krama works through a sequence of phases of awareness; and Pratyabhijna is the philosophical arm that argued the case against the Buddhists and the dualists. The tradition is textual to an unusual degree, and it stands behind a great deal of the tantric material that later moved south and east.

Facts
Origins
Origin Period
from 800 1
Origin Period
to 1200 1
The nondual Shaiva systems of Kashmir reached their classical philosophical formulation, chiefly through Abhinavagupta, within the ninth to twelfth century span the tradition's own scholarship gives for its flourishing; a smaller Kashmiri Pandit lineage carried the tradition forward afterward.
Place of Origin
Kashmir, in the ninth century. 1
Founder
Traditionally traced to the sage Vasugupta, who is said to have received the Shiva Sutras around the ninth century. 2
Organisation
Governance
No central authority 1
Its own record states outright "It is also not a single school", naming Trika, Spanda, Krama and Pratyabhijna as genuinely separate sub-schools.
Ordination
Authority conferred by initiation rather than by ordination 1
Authority to teach and practice passes through tantric initiation, diksha, given by a guru to a disciple, rather than through a formal ordination into an office.
Status
Status Today
Living tradition, practised today 2
Belief
Defining Doctrinal Position
Shiva as the supreme reality 2
Position Profile
Key Text
The Shiva Sutras and the Pratyabhijna (Recognition) treatises of Utpaladeva and Abhinavagupta. 2
Practice
Liturgical Language
Sanskrit 1
Its own record calls the tradition "textual to an unusual degree", matching Shaivism, already carried as sanskrit.
Learn More
Thirty-Six Levels, and the Five Cloaks That Limit a Self

The system takes the twenty-five principles of Samkhya and puts eleven more above them, which is the clearest way to see what it is doing. Samkhya stops at purusha and prakriti, a consciousness and a nature that have nothing to say to each other. Kashmir Shaivism continues upward through the pure levels, Shiva and Shakti at the top as the light of awareness and its own act of noticing itself, then sadashiva, ishvara and shuddhavidya, each a further step in which the I and the this separate a little more.

Between the pure levels and the ordinary world stands maya, which here is not illusion in the Advaita sense but a real power of concealment. Under it operate the five kanchukas, the cloaks, and they are the mechanism by which unlimited awareness becomes a person. Kala limits the power to act, vidya limits knowledge, raga produces the wanting of particular things, kala in its second sense imposes time, and niyati imposes causal and spatial restriction. What is left when all five are on is a limited subject who feels separate.

The tradition speaks of three impurities as well, the sense of being incomplete, the sense that objects are other, and the residue of action, and the three are removed in different ways. None of this describes something that went wrong. The contraction is held to be a free act of the same awareness that is contracted, which is why the tradition can call the whole thing play.

From Vasugupta to Abhinavagupta, and What Happened After

The literature has a shape that can be followed. The Shiva Sutras, revealed to Vasugupta in the ninth century by the tradition account, are the root text, and the Spanda Karikas that accompany them state the doctrine of the pulse of consciousness. Somananda then wrote the Shivadrishti, and his student Utpaladeva the Ishvarapratyabhijnakarika, which turned the recognition teaching into formal philosophy capable of arguing with Buddhist logicians on their own terms.

Abhinavagupta, working around the year 1000, is the figure who holds the whole together. The Tantraloka is his enormous synthesis of the tantric material, the two Pratyabhijna commentaries are his philosophical work, and he wrote on aesthetics as well, where his account of how an audience tastes an emotion is still read by scholars of Sanskrit poetics who have no interest in his theology. His student Kshemaraja wrote the short Pratyabhijnahridayam, which is where most readers now begin.

What happened afterwards is a matter of transmission rather than of argument. The valley tradition thinned, its texts went south and east and were absorbed into Shaiva Siddhanta, into the Shrividya tradition and into later Hindu tantra, often without the name attached. A householder lineage continued in Kashmir into the twentieth century around Swami Lakshman Joo, whose teaching and the scholarly editions of the same period are why the material is available in English at all.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Belongs to Tradition

Hinduism, Religions

Branch Of

Hinduism, Religions

Contained In

Kashmir Shaivism is a family of Shaiva schools, and its nondualism is defined against the dualist Shaiva Siddhanta that shares the wider tradition with it.

Source Saivism and the Tantric TraditionsAlexis Sanderson

Holds Element

Amarnath Cave, Sacred Sites

The cave lies in the valley in which the Kashmir Shaiva tradition took shape, and the connection is one of place rather than of doctrine.

Chakras, Disciplines

Kashmir Shaiva practice works with the subtle body and the rising energy as an aspect of the recognition of consciousness in itself.

Source Encyclopedia of HinduismDenise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.)
So Ham, Mantras

The school teaches that the repetition is already occurring in the breath and needs only to be noticed, which fits a system whose whole account of liberation is recognition rather than acquisition.

Trishula, Religious Symbols

The Kashmiri schools read the three prongs as the triad of knower, knowing and known resolving into one point, so the figure carries a doctrine rather than serving as an emblem of allegiance.

Held Differently

Kama (Lust), Vices

Kashmir Shaiva non-dualism holds that desire is not foreign to consciousness but its own energy misrecognised, so the path is recognition rather than eradication.

Source Encyclopedia of HinduismDenise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.)
Krodha (Anger), Vices

Kashmir Shaiva non-dualism holds anger, like every passion, as an energy of consciousness misrecognised rather than a foreign intruder to be destroyed.

Source Encyclopedia of HinduismDenise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.)

Objects and Practices of This Tradition

The philosopher who gave Kashmir Shaivism its most complete systematic synthesis

Source Encyclopedia of HinduismDenise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.)

The recognition doctrine is Kashmir Shaivism's own defining philosophical system, naming the Pratyabhijna school.

The founding aphoristic scripture of the non-dual current of Kashmir Shaivism

Founding text of the Spanda school within Kashmir Shaivism

The central systematic text of Kashmir Shaivism

Position On

Ahimsa, Doctrines

Non-injury is held in Kashmir Shaivism.

Source An Introduction to HinduismGavin Flood
Atman, Doctrines

The self is held in Kashmir Shaivism to be identical with Shiva, universal consciousness, and the tradition's non-dualism affirms the world rather than treating it as an appearance to be seen through.

Avidya, Doctrines

Ignorance in Kashmir Shaivism is the self-forgetting by which consciousness contracts, and it is held to be an act of Shiva's own freedom rather than an accident.

Bhakti, Doctrines

Devotion is held in Kashmir Shaivism and is not opposed to knowledge in it: the tradition's devotional poetry is written by the same people who wrote its philosophy.

Brahman, Doctrines

The absolute is held in Kashmir Shaivism to be Shiva, consciousness that is also power and never inert, which is the point on which the tradition parts from Advaita over the same non-dualist claim.

Dana, Doctrines

Giving is held in Kashmir Shaivism.

Dharma, Doctrines

Dharma is held in Kashmir Shaivism.

The teaching lineage is central in Kashmir Shaivism, and the tradition's texts are transmitted through named successions of teachers.

Karma, Doctrines

Karma is held in Kashmir Shaivism, and the tradition holds recognition to end it at a stroke rather than to work it off.

Maya, Doctrines

Kashmir Shaivism holds maya to be a real power of Shiva, one of the sheaths by which consciousness limits itself, and not an illusion that makes the world unreal. This is a rival account of the same term rather than a rejection of it.

Moksha, Doctrines

Liberation in Kashmir Shaivism is recognition rather than acquisition: nothing is gained, and what ends is the failure to see that the self was always Shiva.

Merit and demerit are held in Kashmir Shaivism.

Paramatman, Doctrines

The indwelling supreme self is held in Kashmir Shaivism.

Sakshi, Doctrines

The witness is held in Kashmir Shaivism, and the tradition insists that it is not merely a witness: consciousness here acts as well as observes.

Samadhi, Doctrines

Collected absorption is held in Kashmir Shaivism, and the tradition is known for holding that it can be entered from ordinary states rather than only from withdrawal.

Samsara, Doctrines

Transmigration is held in Kashmir Shaivism as belonging to the state of contraction the tradition holds the self to have entered by its own freedom.

Samskara, Doctrines

Latent impressions are held in Kashmir Shaivism.

Being, consciousness and bliss are held in Kashmir Shaivism, with the tradition adding will, knowledge and action as powers the absolute exercises.

Turiya, Doctrines

The fourth state is held in Kashmir Shaivism, and the tradition adds a further state beyond it in which the fourth pervades the other three rather than standing apart from them.

Related To

The Kashmirian nondual schools and the Shakta traditions share a great deal of apparatus, and Abhinavagupta's Trika is worked out with the Goddess at its centre.

Source Saivism and the Tantric TraditionsAlexis Sanderson

Shri Vidya draws on the Kashmirian nondual philosophy for its theology while keeping its own practice and its own lineage.

Source Saivism and the Tantric TraditionsAlexis Sanderson
Sources
1. The Triadic Heart of Siva: Kaula Tantricism of Abhinavagupta in the Non-dual Shaivism of Kashmir
Paul E. Muller-Ortega, State University of New York Press, 1989Abhinavagupta, the Trika synthesis and the nondual Shaivism of KashmirView the Source
2. The Doctrine of Vibration: An Analysis of the Doctrines and Practices of Kashmir Shaivism
Mark S. G. Dyczkowski, State University of New York Press, 1987the thirty-six tattvas, the kanchukas and the doctrine of vibration
Encyclopedia of Hinduism
Denise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.), Routledge, 2008View the Source
Shiva Sutras: The Yoga of Supreme Identity
Jaideva Singh, Motilal Banarsidass, 1979the Shiva Sutras, Vasugupta and the root literature
An Introduction to Hinduism
Gavin Flood, Cambridge University Press, 1996View the Source
Saivism and the Tantric Traditions
Alexis Sanderson, Routledge, 1988
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

Choose a year to see this entry's facts and connections as the atlas records them at that moment: what it held then, what it held instead, and what it had not yet adopted. Choose Present for the current record.