Divinity Atlas

Sacred Correspondences
Doctrines

Karma

Also Known As Kamma · action and its fruitOriginal Term karman (Sanskrit, action)
Action, Rebirth and Consequence

Citation Formats

General Reference

APA Style

BibTeX

Origin 800 BCE to 500 BCE

Karma means action, and by extension the consequence that action carries. The general principle is shared: what is done conditions what follows, across lives as well as within them. Beneath that the traditions differ enough that a single account of karma would misrepresent all of them.

It is not divine judgement. In the classical formulations nobody sits in judgement, no sentence is passed, and no record is kept by an official. The process is closer to a natural regularity than to a court, and it is impersonal in the way that a law of physics is impersonal. Some Hindu theistic schools do bring God in as the agency that dispenses the fruits of action, on the argument that unconscious residues cannot arrange their own consequences, but that is a specific theological addition made in the face of a recognised difficulty, not the default meaning of the word.

Buddhism makes karma a matter of intention. The Buddha's reported identification of action with volition is the pivot of the Buddhist account, and it moves the whole subject inward: an act done without intention does not carry the same weight, and the mental disposition rather than the outward event is what conditions the future.

Jainism is the outlier and the most concrete. Karma there is a subtle material substance which flows into the soul and adheres to it, obscuring its innate qualities in something like the way dust obscures a surface. This is not a metaphor within the system. It explains why Jain practice is organised around stopping the influx and shedding what has accumulated, and why Jain asceticism is more severe than its neighbours: if the problem is accreted matter, then austerity is a technique for removing it.

The popular English use, in which karma means an ironic comeuppance arriving promptly, has almost no relation to any of these.

Facts
Belief
Defining Doctrinal Position
Buddhist teaching ties karma to intention rather than to the act alone, and holds that its effects can be altered by later action rather than being fixed like fate; Hindu and Jain formulations vary in how mechanically karma is held to operate. 2
Status
Status Within the Tradition
Standard teaching, not formally defined 1Tradition: Hinduism
The received law of action and consequence
Doctrinal Category
Action, Rebirth and Consequence 1
Tradition
Scriptural Basis
The concept is expounded across the Upanishads, the Bhagavad Gita and the Pali Canon, each within its own doctrinal framework. 1
Origins
Origin Period
800 BCE to 500 BCE 1
Held By
Hinduism; Buddhism; Jainism; Sikhism 1
The Claim
The Claim
That intentional action generates consequences for the actor, binding future experience, whether in this life or across rebirths, to past deeds. 2
Learn More
Action and Its Fruit, Not Divine Judgement

Karma means, literally, "action," and in its doctrinal sense it is the principle that actions carry consequences that return to the actor. It is emphatically not reward and punishment handed down by a god: it is closer to an impersonal law of the moral universe, in which deeds ripen into results across this life and future ones, without a judge deciding each case.

The idea appears in developed form in the older Upanishads, which forge the link between action, rebirth and the moral quality of a life, the Brihadaranyaka teaches that a person becomes good by good action and bad by bad. The Bhagavad Gita then reframes the problem: since all embodied life involves action, the way out cannot be inaction but karma yoga, acting without attachment to the fruits, so that deeds no longer bind. From these roots karma became the shared grammar of the Indian religions, and, precisely because it is shared, a term the traditions fill with substantially different content.

Three Traditions, Three Mechanisms

The atlas keeps the traditions' accounts distinct, because they disagree about what karma is and what carries it.

In Hinduism, broadly, karma attaches to the enduring self (atman) and binds it to the round of rebirth; its store can be worked off, and various paths, disciplined action, knowledge, and above all loving devotion, can offset or dissolve it, some schools holding that God's grace can cancel karmic debt outright. In Buddhism, karma is redefined as intention: "It is intention (cetana) that I call karma," the Buddha says in the Anguttara Nikaya; what ripens is the moral quality of the will behind an act. Because Buddhism denies a permanent self, it must explain how karma is carried without a soul to carry it, and answers with an unbroken causal continuity rather than a transmigrating substance. In Jainism, karma is the most literal of all: a kind of subtle matter that actually flows into the soul (jiva) and sticks to it, weighing it down, so that liberation requires both stopping the inflow and burning off the accumulated matter through austerity. The same word thus names a moral law, a psychology of intention, and a physics of the soul.

Cross-Tradition Connections

Affirmed By

Reconciliation: affirmed Belief -> contested Doctrine concept (Karma).

Belongs to Tradition

Buddhism, Religions
Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)
Hinduism, Religions
Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)
Jainism, Religions
Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.
Sikhism, Religions
Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.
Zen, Denominations

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.

Held Differently

Nichiren, Denominations

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.
Pure Land, Denominations

Karma, action and its consequence, is affirmed as the mechanism of rebirth across Buddhist schools, including this tradition.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.
Lingayatism, Denominations

Karma is held in Lingayatism.

Source Encyclopedia of HinduismDenise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.)
Nichiren Shoshu, Denominations

Karma is held in Nichiren Shoshu.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.

Depicted In

The museum's own published description of this specific object identifies the wheel's inner ring, the three poisons of ignorance, attachment and aversion, and the second ring as the karmic mechanism itself: negative action driven by the three poisons carries a being downward through the wheel, right motivation and right action carry a being upward.

Source Wheel of Life, accession C2006.66.131 (Rubin Museum of Himalayan Art)Rubin Museum of Himalayan Art, catalogue entry; Elena Pakhoutova (Senior Curator) with Smarthistory

Positions on This Question

Karma is held in Advaita as governing the empirical world, and the school's account of the liberated person still living is worked out in terms of which karma is exhausted and which continues to run.

Karma is held in Dvaita as really binding, and dependent throughout on God, who is the one independent reality.

Karma is held in Gaudiya Vaishnavism, and the tradition holds that devotional service cuts through it rather than merely working it off.

Source Encyclopedia of HinduismDenise Cush, Catherine Robinson and Michael York (eds.)
Gelug, Denominations

Karma is held in the Gelug school, and Tsongkhapa's insistence that emptiness leaves cause and effect intact rather than dissolving it is the school's characteristic emphasis on the point.

Source Introduction to Tibetan BuddhismJohn Powers

Karma is held in ISKCON, and devotional service is taught as what frees a person from it.

Source Hare Krishna TransformedE. Burke Rochford Jr.

Karma is held in Jodo Shinshu, and Shinran presses it further than most: the karmic condition of the ordinary being is held to be so complete that no act of that being can be a cause of liberation.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.
Jonang, Denominations

Karma is held in the Jonang school.

Source Introduction to Tibetan BuddhismJohn Powers
Kagyu, Denominations

Karma is held in the Kagyu school.

Source Introduction to Tibetan BuddhismJohn Powers

Karma is held in the Karma Kagyu school.

Source Introduction to Tibetan BuddhismJohn Powers

Karma is held in Kashmir Shaivism, and the tradition holds recognition to end it at a stroke rather than to work it off.

Karma is held in Madhyamaka and analysed there as conventionally real and ultimately empty, agent and act alike being without own-being.

Karma is held in the Nath tradition.

Source Roots of YogaJames Mallinson and Mark Singleton (trans. and eds.)
Source Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyEdward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (eds.)
Nyingma, Denominations

Karma is held in the Nyingma school.

Source Introduction to Tibetan BuddhismJohn Powers

Expressed as apurva, the unseen potency a ritual generates and stores until it ripens.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyEdward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (eds.)
Rinzai, Denominations

Karma is held in the Rinzai school.

Source Zen Buddhism: A History, Volume 2: JapanHeinrich Dumoulin
Sakya, Denominations

Karma is held in the Sakya school.

Source Introduction to Tibetan BuddhismJohn Powers
Samkhya, Denominations

Karma is held in Samkhya as belonging wholly to nature, never to consciousness, which is the school's reason for holding that consciousness is not in fact bound at all.

Karma is held across the Shaiva schools, and in the Siddhanta it is one of three bonds, alongside impurity and the material principle, that Shiva's grace removes.

Source An Introduction to HinduismGavin Flood

Karma is held across the Shakta traditions.

Shingon, Denominations

Karma is held in Shingon.

Source Kukai: Major WorksYoshito S. Hakeda

Karma is held in Shri Vidya.

Karma is held in Smartism, and the tradition's domestic ritual calendar is organised around obligations that are held to matter.

Source An Introduction to HinduismGavin Flood

Karma is held in Soka Gakkai, and the movement's teaching of human revolution is presented as the transformation of one's own karma by practice within this lifetime.

Soto, Denominations

Karma is held in the Soto school.

Source Zen Buddhism: A History, Volume 2: JapanHeinrich Dumoulin

Karma is held in Sri Vaishnavism as really binding, which is why the tradition holds that release requires an act on God's part.

Tendai, Denominations

Karma is held in Tendai.

Source The Princeton Dictionary of BuddhismRobert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr.
Tiantai, Denominations

Karma is held in Tiantai.

Expressed as adrishta, the unseen force carrying past action forward.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyEdward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (eds.)

Karma is held across the Vaishnava schools, and every school of the current holds that devotion or grace can cut it short rather than only exhaust it.

Source An Introduction to HinduismGavin Flood

Karma is held in Vishishtadvaita as really binding the really existing soul, which is why release requires God's act and not only the soul's insight.

Explained through the alayavijnana, which carries the seeds (bija) of past action forward to ripen.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyEdward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (eds.)

Rejected Here

Charvaka, Philosophical Schools

Denies karma and rebirth outright, along with any afterlife.

Source Stanford Encyclopedia of PhilosophyEdward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman (eds.)

Related To

The mechanism by which an unwholesome act produces its result.

The mechanism papa and punya describe: residues of action ripening into result.

Source Encyclopedia of ReligionMircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.)
Sources
1. An Introduction to Hinduism
Gavin Flood, Cambridge University Press, 1996On karma and rebirth in Hinduism, with the Buddhist and Jain contrastsView the Source
2. The Foundations of Buddhism
Rupert Gethin, Oxford University Press, 1998View the Source
The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism
Robert E. Buswell Jr. and Donald S. Lopez Jr., Princeton University Press, 2014View the Source
Bhagavad Gita
Traditionally attributed to Vyasa, Trubner & Co., 18852.47 and 3.4-9, on action, non-attachment to fruits, and karma yogaView the Source
Encyclopedia of Religion
Mircea Eliade (ed.); Lindsay Jones (ed., 2nd ed.), Macmillan Reference, 2005View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0 open reader challenges)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

View At A Past Year

Choose a year to see this entry's facts and connections as the atlas records them at that moment: what it held then, what it held instead, and what it had not yet adopted. Choose Present for the current record.